Making Democracy Real - The argument for legislative juries
"Making Democracy Real” proposes that, in order to benefit from the full spectrum of our nation’s citizenry, legislatures should be chosen the way juries are – by random selection.
A real democracy has two legs: voting by legislative bodies on matters of policy; and choosing those who do that voting by random selection -- thus garnering a descriptively proportional representation of the American people.
Citizens who wish to place themselves in the lottery for selection could be first required to pass the naturalization test to show basic competence and understanding of the civic structure.
This would create a legislature that met the criteria of a true democracy -- one that was descriptively representative of all the people.

6 comments
Clay Shentrup • about 13 years ago
I'm a co-founder of The Center for Election Science, and I've also given this idea a lot of thought. I could even see the juries being convened for each law, the same way juries are convened for a particular case. It's proportional representation on steroids.
David Grant • about 13 years ago
It's the original true democracy.
Take a look at the Equality-by-Lot blog on WordPress. Lots of serious academic inquiry.
Tom Kniest • about 13 years ago
I'm ready, willing, and able to serve
Ad van der Ven • about 13 years ago
Volunteers vs. Conscripts
Brian Martin is speaking of "chosen randomly from volunteers". León states "that first of all, the job (the function of governor) must not be liked". The latter seems much more appropriate. Somebody who wants to be chosen should already be suspected, because for him/her public interest will be contaminated by individual interest. Actually, León speaks about conscripts.
David Grant • about 13 years ago
There is an attractive element to that statement ("the function must not be liked"). It enhances the idea of service and duty.
But rather than a coercive draft, wouldn't a legislative jury of willing and able 'lawmakers of our peers' be preferable?
Ad van der Ven • about 13 years ago
Making Democracy Real only works when it is global (world wide). Go to:
http://www.socsci.kun.nl/~advdv/lottocracy.html
Have fun.